'Don't light up' says Hertfordshire County Council, as it invests £24m in British American Tobacco

Watford Observer: 'Don't light up' says council, as it invests £24m in tobacco firm 'Don't light up' says council, as it invests £24m in tobacco firm

A ruling Hertfordshire politician has defended the decision to launch a countywide anti-smoking campaign while the council has more than £20 million invested in a tobacco company.

The new policy, which describes smoking as “an unacceptable cost to Hertfordshire”, was drawn up after the county council took over the responsibility for public health from the NHS in April.

However, the county council’s pension managers still ploughed £23.9 million into British American Tobacco this year, the largest single investment in the fund.

Following the revelation, the council has faced calls to review its pension fund so it could “demonstrate a level of consistency”.

This week, the county council said it had a responsibility to get the best value for the taxpayer from its pension fund investments.

Derrick Ashley, cabinet member for resources and transformation, said: “Our pension fund managers have a legal duty to make sound investment decisions to secure the best long-term returns for the pension fund. At present, this may include investments in tobacco companies and those that sell tobacco products.

“However, where possible we seek to align pension investments with our policies.

“In light of this, and our statutory responsibilities for public health, the pensions committee has been asked to consider how, while still fulfilling its legal duty and not adding cost to the public purse, it might be able to align its portfolio of investment with the principles and intentions in the council’s policy statement on tobacco control.”

He continued: “It is crucial future Council Tax payers don’t have to pick up the bill for the pension fund.”

According to the county council, smoking is the largest cause of preventable death in Hertfordshire, killing 1,700 people a year – more than the next six most common causes of death combined.

The anti-smoking policy, discussed on Monday, said the council “intends to continue to reduce smoking prevalence with focused, sustained and co-ordinated action on a number of fronts”.

Councillors and officers were also told to refuse any partnerships, payments, gifts or services from the tobacco industry.

It asked pension fund trustees to “align their portfolio of investment” with the new smoking policy, as long as it didn’t affect their legal duty or profits.

The new policy highlights a particular difficulty in convincing “black and minority ethnic communities” to give up smoking, for cultural reasons.

British American Tobacco sold an extra five billion cigarettes in Asia during the first six months of this year compared with the same time last year, while sales in all other regions dropped.

Sales increased in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Vietnam, South Korea, Indonesia and Philippines, resulting in profits of £875 million, up by £60 million compared to 2012.

The number of cigarettes sold in the first six months of this year dropped in the Americas, Europe, Eastern Europe, Middle East and Africa, although profits were still made.

The company, which has its headquarters in London and produces Dunhill, Lucky Strike, Kent and Pall Mall cigarettes, made global profits of £5.97 billion last year but did not pay a penny of UK corporation tax.

While smoking generates £227 million a year in tax, the bill for health care and associated costs are an estimated £278 million a year, leaving the Hertfordshire taxpayer £50 million out of pocket.

A spokesman for British American Tobacco said any profit made in the UK was cancelled out by its operating costs for its offices, and that in 2011 £1.447 billion of global corporation tax was paid.

The county council’s pension fund also covers workers in local councils, Watford, Three Rivers, Hertsmere and Dacorum.

Politicians at Watford Borough Council voted unanimously for a Labour motion to bring in standardised unbranded packaging, at a meeting on Wednesday, November 20.

The motion argued the initiative would make smoking less attractive to young people.

Comments (5)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

1:31pm Fri 29 Nov 13

BigBadVirgil says...

So what? At the end of the day, the pension scheme is something that is for workers, to get the best payment when they choose to retire...
So what? At the end of the day, the pension scheme is something that is for workers, to get the best payment when they choose to retire... BigBadVirgil

12:56am Sat 30 Nov 13

wd40 says...

The obvious problem here is that the approach by the managers of the pension fund is not in line with the authorities policies. If the NHS pension funds were to be invested into BAT there would be a public outcry. Its only reasonable to expect the council to invest their pension funds into ethical bodies.

Oh and BTW BAT paid no UK tax how bl**dy ethical is that it is the publics money that goes into paying the pension and the public have a right to expect that it is invested not only wisely but ethically.

Come on you pension fund managers do the right thing by us all.
The obvious problem here is that the approach by the managers of the pension fund is not in line with the authorities policies. If the NHS pension funds were to be invested into BAT there would be a public outcry. Its only reasonable to expect the council to invest their pension funds into ethical bodies. Oh and BTW BAT paid no UK tax how bl**dy ethical is that it is the publics money that goes into paying the pension and the public have a right to expect that it is invested not only wisely but ethically. Come on you pension fund managers do the right thing by us all. wd40

2:55am Sat 30 Nov 13

Paul Barbara says...

'British American Tobacco sold an extra five billion cigarettes in Asia during the first six months of this year compared with the same time last year, while sales in all other regions dropped.

Sales increased in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Vietnam, South Korea, Indonesia and Philippines, resulting in profits of £875 million, up by £60 million compared to 2012...' That makes it even worse. These countries have even less money to spend on health care than Herts Council.

If profits are King, why on earth don't the council invest in gun-running, drug smuggling, **** and people traficking? Even more lucrative than fags ('Ethics? I say, it's all about profits, my man! We Toffs gave up smoking long ago, like the doctors. Only Plebs smoke, and mostly foreigners at that').
'British American Tobacco sold an extra five billion cigarettes in Asia during the first six months of this year compared with the same time last year, while sales in all other regions dropped. Sales increased in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Vietnam, South Korea, Indonesia and Philippines, resulting in profits of £875 million, up by £60 million compared to 2012...' That makes it even worse. These countries have even less money to spend on health care than Herts Council. If profits are King, why on earth don't the council invest in gun-running, drug smuggling, **** and people traficking? Even more lucrative than fags ('Ethics? I say, it's all about profits, my man! We Toffs gave up smoking long ago, like the doctors. Only Plebs smoke, and mostly foreigners at that'). Paul Barbara

9:35am Sat 30 Nov 13

Hornets number 12 fan says...

Politics and hypocrisy have always been bedfellows! This is far from a surprise to me or anyone else! Think of all the tax income thats been lost because Smoking has been made to be a social lepers pastime? and the NHS is STILL on it's knees even with all these non smokers about!! Lack of tobacco tax maybe?
Politics and hypocrisy have always been bedfellows! This is far from a surprise to me or anyone else! Think of all the tax income thats been lost because Smoking has been made to be a social lepers pastime? and the NHS is STILL on it's knees even with all these non smokers about!! Lack of tobacco tax maybe? Hornets number 12 fan

11:19pm Sat 30 Nov 13

PCllrRRidley says...

Pension funds invest, pensioners benefit, when did you think ethics played a part,
Pension funds invest, pensioners benefit, when did you think ethics played a part, PCllrRRidley

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree