News RSS Feed


Observer Owl

Girl run over in Chorleywood

10:36am Tuesday 8th January 2008

comment Comments (87)   Have your say »


A 17-year-old girl is seriously ill after being involved in an accident with a van this morning as she crossed Rickmansworth Road, near St Clement Danes School.

Police say the accident happened at around 8.25am this morning as rush hour traffic reached its peak.

The girl, believed to be a pupil at the school, was rushed to Watford General Hospital where she remains in a serious condition.

The vehicle involved was a white Renault Kangoo van.

Anyone who witnessed the accident is asked to contact PC Alison Hickman of the Western Area Roads Policing Unit of 07923 472 388.

The road remains closed from the junction with Common Road. Traffic towards the M25 is being diverted through the centre of Chorleywood.


Your Say YourWatford Observer

Mike, Amersham says...
11:30am Tue 8 Jan 08

There should be a pelican crossing here to make it safer for people to cross the road.

On the other hand, if parents insist on driving their kids to school, they just make the traffic worse and more dangerous to cross the road.

The traffic here is not a problem when the school is shut.

http://www.walktosch
ool.org.uk/

Nicky, Chorleywood says...
12:08pm Tue 8 Jan 08

The road is a very fast and busy road. I do agree that a pelican crossing should be put in place. Parents do tend to drop off there kids accross the road from the school, which is dangerous. There is a carpark in the school grounds, so parents should use it and maybe this sort of accident can be avoided.

Parent, says...
12:47pm Tue 8 Jan 08

Mike I would happily let my kids take the bus to school if it did not cost £4.50 per day. Costs me less than 50p to drive them. Also the local authority has for years let people from outside the area come to the school. Dont blame the parents

Anxious Parent, Chorleywood says...
1:15pm Tue 8 Jan 08

Surely there must now be a crossing on this road. The school car park is so small it cannot cope with the amount of teachers/6th formers cars let alone parents dropping off children. There is a queue into school morning and night and this makes it very dangerous for children crossing between 'parked' cars on one side of the road and fast moving traffic on the other side.

Roger Mellie, Out there says...
1:37pm Tue 8 Jan 08

Walking cost nothing, so we can save you the 50p also!! Just how disabled are your kids Parent? or are you actually one of the people you despise and from out of the area? I feel sorry for the poor girl she's probably one of the kids that do walk, turn up on time and behave themselves.

arsenal fan, by my computer says...
1:41pm Tue 8 Jan 08

I wish a speedy recovery to the teenager.
I do not know the area but reading comments,I think that there should be traffic lights put up and speed bumps put in the rd.

Martin Trevett, Chorleywood says...
2:13pm Tue 8 Jan 08

If concerned people would contact me as one of your local Lib Dem councillors, we have been working on this issue for some time we are campaining for a reduction in the speed limit and rephasing of the traffic lights to allow for pedestrians to cross, support from residents and parents will help, please contact me.

Anna Rack, Watford says...
2:28pm Tue 8 Jan 08

I wondered, was the driver on the mobile phone at the time?
One hopes that the girl makes a full recovery. Best wishes. Anna

Kate, Herts says...
2:30pm Tue 8 Jan 08

Roger Mellie most kids at clement danes don't live close enough to walk and to be honest walking isn't exactly the safest option this day and age,my children have to travel to Watford to school even though we live closer to Clement Danes than any other school,the school is in much need of a crossing I believe.

annonymous, Chorleywood says...
2:48pm Tue 8 Jan 08

How many people are going to get hurt on this road before a crossing gets put in ? Every other school in the area has a crossing, why should this school be any different ?

sue powell, chorleywood says...
3:30pm Tue 8 Jan 08

My kids have walked for years but they still have to cross the road somewhere. There is no crossing suitable nearby and the car park is not available to 6th form, they have to park across the road. This was an accident waiting to happen and I will willingly sign any campaign to get a safe crossing put here.

Chancellor, Economics Class says...
3:38pm Tue 8 Jan 08

Parent - so the cost of using the bus is £22.50 a week. The RAC (in 2006) estimated that the cost of running a car is £106 a week (tax, fuel, depreciation, insurance etc). Therefore, it's more than 4 times more expensive for you to drive them door to door - and not to mention the impact on the environment.

Anyway - safety is the topic here. I wish the girl in question makes a full recovery. And lets not be too quick to blame the driver - I've seen kids run/walk across that road without too much regard for their own safety.

annonymous, chorleywood says...
3:55pm Tue 8 Jan 08

How exactly, are you supposed to cross that road ? None of the cars stop, most are exceeding the speed limit. So if you walk, you are in more danger, than driving. If you live on the left approaching the school, you will have to cross Common Road, if you live on the right you have to cross Chenies Road. Either way you have to cross a road, which is very dangerous.

Chris, Chorleywood says...
4:25pm Tue 8 Jan 08

The Chancellor's arithmetic is wrong. It is not 4 times more expensive to drive than to take the bus. The RAC estimated £106 a week cost of running a car is based on one's total weekly mileage, not merely the school runs. But I agree with him that safety is the issue here and the risks remain.

J Williams, 346-080 says...
4:27pm Tue 8 Jan 08

I pass this school every morning on my way to work and there are no words to describe the massive difference in volumne of traffic in term time to school holiday time, but it takes me TWICE as long to get to work just because of this stretch of road and the school. I appreciate some pupils live too far away to walk but I see car after car with one child in it so shared school runs would help and these are senior school pupils so should not need to the door pampering so perhaps they could be dropped off half a mile away and then walk. The government goes on about the carbon foot print and the school run is a major problem so lets see them do something like the American school bus service for free!

annonymous, Chorleywood says...
4:42pm Tue 8 Jan 08

Shouldn't all kids have the right to get to school how we like and do so safely ?

Andy, Croxley Green says...
4:42pm Tue 8 Jan 08

J Williams wrote:
I pass this school every morning on my way to work and there are no words to describe the massive difference in volumne of traffic in term time to school holiday time, but it takes me TWICE as long to get to work just because of this stretch of road and the school. I appreciate some pupils live too far away to walk but I see car after car with one child in it so shared school runs would help and these are senior school pupils so should not need to the door pampering so perhaps they could be dropped off half a mile away and then walk. The government goes on about the carbon foot print and the school run is a major problem so lets see them do something like the American school bus service for free!
perhaps incorporating a school park and ride were parents can drop their children off and board a scholl bus at no cost?

Joe schmo, says...
4:54pm Tue 8 Jan 08

Its a tragedy. I sincerely hope she will be ok.

No one is to blame apart from perhaps herself. Take more care crossing the road, as you endangering others aswell as yourself.

Seymour Laws, Chorleywood says...
5:00pm Tue 8 Jan 08

J Williams' complaint about traffic volume, exacebated by single occupancy cars, fails to tell us who he/she shares a car with on the way to work, or why (given that the road in question (A412) runs parrallel to the underground and Chiltern over-land service)he/she is not on the train; or why he/she is driving at all and not on a bike - if the time to get past one school doubles the travel time the total journey distance cannot be more than 10 miles? It is always great whe motorists blame everyone else on the road for congestion, carbon emission etc.

parent, herts says...
5:01pm Tue 8 Jan 08

Roger Mellie, your point can be completely disregarded. Even children living in chorleywood have a long walk to the school, let alone the children living in Mill End, Croxley etc. For some, buses are too expensive which is no fault of their own. I think you should travel to school how you like. Maybe if the price of public transport decreased, the incentive to use it would increase and then the number of parents dropping kids to school would decrease. But there is definately no need to use the word disabled. Totally unecessary and to some extent, offensive. Hopefully a speedy recovery for the girl.

Igloo, Watford says...
5:17pm Tue 8 Jan 08

Martin Trevett wrote:
If concerned people would contact me as one of your local Lib Dem councillors, we have been working on this issue for some time we are campaining for a reduction in the speed limit and rephasing of the traffic lights to allow for pedestrians to cross, support from residents and parents will help, please contact me.
Obviously not "working" hard enough like Giles Medhurst who is the official Lib Dem spokesperson on the Herfordshire County Council Highways & Transport Panel.

Lloyd, Chorleywood says...
5:49pm Tue 8 Jan 08

It is disappointing to see so many people using this dreadful incident to promote their own tiresome causes and opinions.

That said, I have never really understood how car journeys made on the 'school run' are somehow deamed less worthy than, say, the use of a vehicle to travel to and from work. Surely parents should be free to choose how their children make the trip to school without incurring the opprobium of other road users?

Let us all join in wishing the injured child a full and speedy recovery.

martin Trevett, chorleywood says...
6:11pm Tue 8 Jan 08

Igloo wrote:
Martin Trevett wrote:
If concerned people would contact me as one of your local Lib Dem councillors, we have been working on this issue for some time we are campaining for a reduction in the speed limit and rephasing of the traffic lights to allow for pedestrians to cross, support from residents and parents will help, please contact me.
Obviously not "working" hard enough like Giles Medhurst who is the official Lib Dem spokesperson on the Herfordshire County Council Highways & Transport Panel.
I am afraid the County Council is run by a party other than mine and in spite of taking over two thirds of our Council Tax it fails to put enough of our money into road saftey, perhaps it is time you looked outside your igloo.

Stan Gallagher, Chorleywood says...
6:29pm Tue 8 Jan 08

A more recent report on the Watford Observer website says that the girl has been transferred from Watford General to the Royal Free Hospital in London suffering from what are thought to be severe head injuries.

Thoughts for the girl and her family would seem rather more appropriate at this time than contributions such as those made by Igloo.

J, Croxley says...
6:43pm Tue 8 Jan 08

Name another school in the county with a 40mph, and just out of view in the photo, a national speed limit road outside.

This is preventable, but right now our thoughts have to be elsewhere, action not words make a difference.

Kate, herts says...
7:10pm Tue 8 Jan 08

I truly hope this young lady recovers from this awful accident, my thoughts are with her and her family x

Concerned parent, Chorleywood says...
7:43pm Tue 8 Jan 08

Let me begin by saying that my thoughts and prayers are with the girl and her family.

I have always been surprised that there is no speed camera on this stretch of road (by a school!), but in other locations - e.g. by the roundabout by Chalfont St. Peter - there is a speed camera and a 30mph limit. Where is the sense in that? This is why some people (probably unfairly) have doubts about the considerations which are taken into account when locating speed cameras.

I would have thought that all roads near schools should be 30mph and enforced by speed cameras.

I raised concerns (at a local residents meeting) about the speed in which cars travelled on roads near The Russell School, but my concerns did not seem to be shared by those people without young children.

Don't get me on the subject of driving whilkst using a hand-held mobile phone.



Anon, says...
7:43pm Tue 8 Jan 08

Is there any more information regarding the cause of this tragic accident?

We are researching accidents involving pedestrians who run into the road from the cover of large stationary vehicles.
If anyone has any information could you please post it as we are working on systems that will prevent such accidents.

We hope for a full and speedy recovery.

C, Chorleywood says...
9:58pm Tue 8 Jan 08

I know the girl that was knocked down and i am shocked that people are being so quick to judge yet they clearly have no clue. No one is to blame for this except the council, it is neglengence on their part. I do not know of another school that has a 40mph limit leading into the national speed limit with no crossing... normally people say why does it take something bad to happen before any action is taken... even after this incident the man in charge at the council said there simply isn't enough funds for traffic lights... it's not good enough. I can think of things where money is completely wasted yet someone has been badly hurt and i'm sure she wont be the last.
As for you people driving and complaining of the traffic at least these youths are doing something with their lives... i'm sure you would be the first to complain if they were out causing trouble in the day when they could be at school. And why on earth would parents let their children walk to school when there are goodness knows how many weirdos around nowadays, it simply isn't safe. If you're so worried about the carbon print then why are you driving to work, get up earlier and walk...?
Idiots, some people don't have a clue!!

alex, pinner says...
9:59pm Tue 8 Jan 08

the school has student traveling over 9 miles to schools each day once those students are able to drive it is the cheepest way for them to get to school however the council doesnt allow the school to expand its car park which would stop people parking over the road and allow parents to drop off their children, especially as there is no realy usable public transport to the school. the 6th form students recently made a proposal in the form of a petition to the govoners who then wrote back saying it was out of their hands. so when all the corespondents and petition were passed onto the council by post they failed to respond twice. why doesn't the loacal council do something to stop the problem by using the available space for sensible parking of implementing a regular bus service to some of the loacal towns which is affordable.

Motorist, S.Oxhey says...
11:40pm Tue 8 Jan 08

I am disgusted that it seems its always the driver that gets the blame. I was driving along Hayling Road, S.Oxhey just before the Christmas holidaysand a young girl of approx 15years from St.Michaels school, walked out in front of my car and carried on walking slowly, ignoring me tooting her. Her friends on the other side of the road were laughing at her, would they have been laughing at her had I been doing 30mph, bearing in mind that i had just turned into the road, i might possibly had knocked her down, who would have been laughing then her, her friends, her family. This was down to pure ignorance. Im not saying who is at fault with this young girls accident but we must remember that we cannot always blame the motorists as pedestrians are to blame just as much. My daughter gets the bus to school and it costs me £150.00 a term but I just dont have a choice but to pay this.

A concerned parent, Chorleywood says...
11:48pm Tue 8 Jan 08

I think it would be helpul if someone (Martin Trevett?) explained where competency resides on road safety. In other words, what is the split of reponsibility between the Highways Agency, Police, County Council and Local Council.

In particular,

Who ultimately decides what is an appropriate speed limit on such a road (and who is usually involved in the decision making process)?

I would really like an answer to this question.


Who decides on the location of speed cameras?

I don't think anybody should be critical of Mr Trevett. He is being transparent and offering his assistance. An honest approach when others might be taking a low profile.

mcadam, currently Leeds, Watford says...
11:55pm Tue 8 Jan 08

Ive been at Danes 8 years and still nothing has been done about this road. It's a harsh way to be proved right, but finally something may be done. Lets hope.

Wish you a speedy recovery chloe!

A. Concerned parent, Chorleywood says...
11:57pm Tue 8 Jan 08

Anxious parent (above) made a very good point

"There is a queue into school morning and night and this makes

it very dangerous for children crossing between 'parked' cars on one side of the road and fast moving traffic on the other side."

The larger the "catchment area" for the school, the more traffic there will be. St. Clement Danes should be a secondary school for the LOCAL community. As should every secondary school.

I understand that it is quite safe for children to walk up Green Street and then across a footpath to the school.

L, USA says...
4:07am Wed 9 Jan 08

Get well soon.

A Friend, Bushey says...
9:07am Wed 9 Jan 08

Motorist wrote:
I am disgusted that it seems its always the driver that gets the blame. I was driving along Hayling Road, S.Oxhey just before the Christmas holidaysand a young girl of approx 15years from St.Michaels school, walked out in front of my car and carried on walking slowly, ignoring me tooting her. Her friends on the other side of the road were laughing at her, would they have been laughing at her had I been doing 30mph, bearing in mind that i had just turned into the road, i might possibly had knocked her down, who would have been laughing then her, her friends, her family. This was down to pure ignorance. Im not saying who is at fault with this young girls accident but we must remember that we cannot always blame the motorists as pedestrians are to blame just as much. My daughter gets the bus to school and it costs me £150.00 a term but I just dont have a choice but to pay this.
nine of ten cases it is the drivers fault - now many men & women still use their mobile phones whilst driving a good 80%. Perhaps if was your child it would be different yes pedestians are at fault thats human mature.

A suggestion is for for parients to draw up a rota to provide road crossing marshals until the solution is found?

Luke, Croxley Green says...
9:16am Wed 9 Jan 08

St Clement Danes School is there an adjacent field that could be adapted to a parking area for parients to use?

Tony nelson, Chorleywood says...
9:48am Wed 9 Jan 08

I am sure we all hope for a speedy recovery for the injured girl.

The key issue is the 40 mph speed limit and lack of safe crossing points. Putting these in place will make it safer for pedestrians. I am writing to local and county councillors and am heartened to see how much interest there is on the issue. Over 10 years I have not seen the local or county councils take action on this issue. Now is the time to raise our voices and say what we want as parents. It is not about blame - but about accident prevention.

Luke, Croxley Green says...
10:12am Wed 9 Jan 08

Tony nelson wrote:
I am sure we all hope for a speedy recovery for the injured girl. The key issue is the 40 mph speed limit and lack of safe crossing points. Putting these in place will make it safer for pedestrians. I am writing to local and county councillors and am heartened to see how much interest there is on the issue. Over 10 years I have not seen the local or county councils take action on this issue. Now is the time to raise our voices and say what we want as parents. It is not about blame - but about accident prevention.
Speed bumps and speed limited to 30mph for 400 yards each side of school - what has the local MP have to say on the subject?

Motorist, S.Oxhey says...
11:48am Wed 9 Jan 08

A Friend wrote:
Motorist wrote: I am disgusted that it seems its always the driver that gets the blame. I was driving along Hayling Road, S.Oxhey just before the Christmas holidaysand a young girl of approx 15years from St.Michaels school, walked out in front of my car and carried on walking slowly, ignoring me tooting her. Her friends on the other side of the road were laughing at her, would they have been laughing at her had I been doing 30mph, bearing in mind that i had just turned into the road, i might possibly had knocked her down, who would have been laughing then her, her friends, her family. This was down to pure ignorance. Im not saying who is at fault with this young girls accident but we must remember that we cannot always blame the motorists as pedestrians are to blame just as much. My daughter gets the bus to school and it costs me £150.00 a term but I just dont have a choice but to pay this.
nine of ten cases it is the drivers fault - now many men & women still use their mobile phones whilst driving a good 80%. Perhaps if was your child it would be different yes pedestians are at fault thats human mature. A suggestion is for for parients to draw up a rota to provide road crossing marshals until the solution is found?
Ive taught my child to cross the road properly ,and why does it always come to down to mobile phone use, a lot of it is driving too fast and lack of concentration, why has nobody mentioned drink driving.

Observer, Beaconsfield says...
11:55am Wed 9 Jan 08

Walking/cycling to school is the answer to this country's obesity problem (and would certainly cut traffic congestion). To drive your kids to school just because 'there are weirdos out there' is just ludicrous. How are kids ever supposed to learn and experience things if they are not allowed to do things on their own?!

I agree with some here that the problem is that too many people are driving to this school - either 6 formers or parents dropping off/picking up. Congested roads are more dangerous (for pedestrians) than less congested roads.

Lets tackle the cause rather than try to adapt and live with the problem.

In the meantime, I'm sure this will serve as a reminder to pedestrians and motorists to be more careful.

A Friend, Bushey says...
12:04pm Wed 9 Jan 08

Motorist wrote:
A Friend wrote:
Motorist wrote: I am disgusted that it seems its always the driver that gets the blame. I was driving along Hayling Road, S.Oxhey just before the Christmas holidaysand a young girl of approx 15years from St.Michaels school, walked out in front of my car and carried on walking slowly, ignoring me tooting her. Her friends on the other side of the road were laughing at her, would they have been laughing at her had I been doing 30mph, bearing in mind that i had just turned into the road, i might possibly had knocked her down, who would have been laughing then her, her friends, her family. This was down to pure ignorance. Im not saying who is at fault with this young girls accident but we must remember that we cannot always blame the motorists as pedestrians are to blame just as much. My daughter gets the bus to school and it costs me £150.00 a term but I just dont have a choice but to pay this.
nine of ten cases it is the drivers fault - now many men & women still use their mobile phones whilst driving a good 80%. Perhaps if was your child it would be different yes pedestians are at fault thats human mature. A suggestion is for for parients to draw up a rota to provide road crossing marshals until the solution is found?
Ive taught my child to cross the road properly ,and why does it always come to down to mobile phone use, a lot of it is driving too fast and lack of concentration, why has nobody mentioned drink driving.
truth hurts how many parients trasporting their children to and from use their mobile phones during the journey a good 80% - **** driving at 9am I dont think so!

Back to mobile phones how many pupils own mobiles and it is noted that these distract the pupils when walking along the pavements or crossing roads?

The council can resolve the issue with school crossing points and barriers

concerned parent of SCD, Chorleywood says...
1:01pm Wed 9 Jan 08

I am appalled by some of the idiotic comments on this site about emmissions and phones etc. This accident has been waiting to happen for the past 7 years at least! The school has asked on many occasions for some traffic calming measures to be put in place but has always been told that there was no money available. I bet some is found now! These are CHILDREN being forced to cross a very dangerous road as there are no crossings for them to use. We should all join the school's campaign and make sure poor Chloe is the last victim of this situation, next time it could be YOUR child. My thoughts are with Chloe and her family. God bless and hope you are back to full fitness soon. x

Statistician, Chorleywood says...
1:41pm Wed 9 Jan 08

1 accident in (at least) 7 years? Hardly an accident blackspot is it?

During my school days, when I missed the bus, I would walk the 3 miles to school by myself. I somehow managed to do this AND avoid colliding with any vehicles or being offered sweets by strange men. The world is no more dangerous now than it was 20 years ago - it's just the media are better at telling us about all the bad things that happen and the Government are better at telling us what's good/bad for us.

larry, Watford says...
2:03pm Wed 9 Jan 08

Its the same story all over the country, several accidents have to happen before the authorities do anything, i remember as a pupil at st michaels garston in the seventies, several accidents before the underpass was built. my best wishes go out to the girl, her family and friends

larry, Watford says...
2:07pm Wed 9 Jan 08

Its the same story all over the country, several accidents have to happen before the authorities do anything, i remember as a pupil at st michaels garston in the seventies, several accidents before the underpass was built. my best wishes go out to the girl, her family and friends

A Friend, Bushey says...
2:10pm Wed 9 Jan 08

concerned parent of SCD wrote:
I am appalled by some of the idiotic comments on this site about emmissions and phones etc. This accident has been waiting to happen for the past 7 years at least! The school has asked on many occasions for some traffic calming measures to be put in place but has always been told that there was no money available. I bet some is found now! These are CHILDREN being forced to cross a very dangerous road as there are no crossings for them to use. We should all join the school\'s campaign and make sure poor Chloe is the last victim of this situation, next time it could be YOUR child. My thoughts are with Chloe and her family. God bless and hope you are back to full fitness soon. x
so concerned parent - what have you done to resolve this!

Have you contacted the local council?

Have you arrange a parents crossing go slow?

Have you done anything in the 7 years - NO clearly not!

Does the school have a board of govenors?

Children are being forced? Do something about it now or there will be futher accidents!

Demand a meeting with all relevant authorities oh no foregot somebody else can do that! Do something these are your children and our future.

CSD parent, Chorleywood says...
2:11pm Wed 9 Jan 08

How many accidents would the Statistician need to see before he accepts that this is a dangerous stretch of road?

Are any of the following risk factors: a busy A road; a 40 mph speed limit, with the national speed limit commencing just around the corner; no pedestrian crossing anyway along that road; no traffic calming measures/speed cameras etc cf the revenue raiser on that 30 mph stretch going into Little Chalfont; the only place for 6th formers to park being on the other side of the road to the school; the traffic on that side regularly quening in the morning, but trafffic on the school side regularly exceeding the 40 mph limit; the bend in the road - all in all it is difficult to imagine a more dangerous crossing point.

Surely traffic engineers, or anyone with any driving experience, can see the obvious dangers without waiting for a tragic accident to occur.

Can the Statistician identify any other schools on an A road, that do not have a crossing?

A Friend, Bushey says...
2:16pm Wed 9 Jan 08

Statistician wrote:
1 accident in (at least) 7 years? Hardly an accident blackspot is it? During my school days, when I missed the bus, I would walk the 3 miles to school by myself. I somehow managed to do this AND avoid colliding with any vehicles or being offered sweets by strange men. The world is no more dangerous now than it was 20 years ago - it's just the media are better at telling us about all the bad things that happen and the Government are better at telling us what's good/bad for us.
Statistician tell that to the parents and family of teenage girl involved.

Im sure if was your daughter your views would be differant?

SCD Parent, Chorleywood says...
2:19pm Wed 9 Jan 08

The Friend from Bushey asks what has been done over the last seven years. The answer is plenty by the School Governors, parents, residents and a number of local Councillors - the response being that nothing can be done until there is an accident.

Given the seriousness of this accident, please reframe from idle uniformed speculation.

concerned parent of SCD, Chorleywood says...
2:25pm Wed 9 Jan 08

In response to A. Friend of Bushey. I have been actively involved in campaigning along with Dr Valentine and the Governers over the past 7 years to push for traffic calming measures to be put into place by Herts CC (including attending traffic planning meetings). Each proposal refused due to lack of perceived need and funds. The police will not allow parent crossings as they say they are dangerous. Saying we should demand meetings with the relevant authority, show how little you understand these things and therefore your stupid comments don't help. It's very easy to sit & criticise others with your sneering comments but we knew this would happen at some point. We don't need our actions criticised, we need the authority in question to accept there is a need. This accident could have been avoided, but it's not for the want of trying on the part of the school to have action taken. Think before you speak, assuming you are right just make you look stupid.

Igloo, Watford says...
2:34pm Wed 9 Jan 08

martin Trevett wrote:
Igloo wrote:
Martin Trevett wrote: If concerned people would contact me as one of your local Lib Dem councillors, we have been working on this issue for some time we are campaining for a reduction in the speed limit and rephasing of the traffic lights to allow for pedestrians to cross, support from residents and parents will help, please contact me.
Obviously not "working" hard enough like Giles Medhurst who is the official Lib Dem spokesperson on the Herfordshire County Council Highways & Transport Panel.
I am afraid the County Council is run by a party other than mine and in spite of taking over two thirds of our Council Tax it fails to put enough of our money into road saftey, perhaps it is time you looked outside your igloo.
So what you're saying is that there is nothing you can do - something I knew all along - so why make put in your two ha'pth in the first place pretending that there is? More running with the hare and hunting with the hounds - typical Fib Dem response - You have Medhurst on the appropriate HCC committee and he's pretty useless too - opportunists ever. All my sympathy goes out to this poor unfortunate girl, her family and friends. I wish her a speedy recovery.

A Friend, Bushey says...
2:54pm Wed 9 Jan 08

concerned parent of SCD wrote:
In response to A. Friend of Bushey. I have been actively involved in campaigning along with Dr Valentine and the Governers over the past 7 years to push for traffic calming measures to be put into place by Herts CC (including attending traffic planning meetings). Each proposal refused due to lack of perceived need and funds. The police will not allow parent crossings as they say they are dangerous. Saying we should demand meetings with the relevant authority, show how little you understand these things and therefore your stupid comments don\'t help. It\'s very easy to sit & criticise others with your sneering comments but we knew this would happen at some point. We don\'t need our actions criticised, we need the authority in question to accept there is a need. This accident could have been avoided, but it\'s not for the want of trying on the part of the school to have action taken. Think before you speak, assuming you are right just make you look stupid.
clearly your policy has failed in 7 years you have failed in your duties as parents! Clearly your local councillor and MP do not have your interest at heart of you or your children!.

My comments are not sneering I would question that in 7 years you have achived nothing!

Does the school have a parents council?

Are there local celebs who would back your worthy fight?

Demanding meetings lets get one thing clear you are the voter and these people are elected by your goodself to carry out there duties to you.

Are there amply school signs making the drivers aware you are approaching the school.

Does the school have a school crossing control supervisor ?

Stupid NO living in the real world yes!

Perhaps a way forward signs on ever side of Chorleywood "You are entering a 30mph zone and the people of Chorleywood thank you for your co-operation" You may have seen these in some local villages.

Luke, Loudwater says...
3:08pm Wed 9 Jan 08

SCD Parent wrote:
The Friend from Bushey asks what has been done over the last seven years. The answer is plenty by the School Governors, parents, residents and a number of local Councillors - the response being that nothing can be done until there is an accident. Given the seriousness of this accident, please reframe from idle uniformed speculation.
SCD Parent "The answer is plenty by the School Governors, parents, residents and a number of local Councillors" and "please reframe from idle uniformed speculation".

Speculation NO you have achived NOTHING in seven years, if you had we would not be at this forum.

And needless to say we would not be reading this terrible article.

Perhaps you all need a little more time say 7 years.

Stop talking and do something.

SCD Parent, Chorleywood says...
3:08pm Wed 9 Jan 08

Dear Friend from Bushey, you obviously do not know the road: there is no school crossing control supervisor because their is no school crossing, or any other crossing. The driver was not entering a 30 mph zone, rather he/she was on an A road in a 40 mph zone hearing to a national speed limit (60 mph zone) just around the corner, so how would you word the sign then?

As you have no knowledge of the situation, why not listen to those who do.

SCD Parent, Chorleywood says...
3:17pm Wed 9 Jan 08

Luke, the dangers and the need for remedial measurss were raised again and again with Herts CC: what that was not done by the school and parents should and could have have been done?

A Friend, Bushey says...
3:20pm Wed 9 Jan 08

SCD Parent wrote:
Dear Friend from Bushey, you obviously do not know the road: there is no school crossing control supervisor because their is no school crossing, or any other crossing. The driver was not entering a 30 mph zone, rather he/she was on an A road in a 40 mph zone hearing to a national speed limit (60 mph zone) just around the corner, so how would you word the sign then? As you have no knowledge of the situation, why not listen to those who do.
Oh you do, I think not

So itsan "A" road there is nothing to stop the Highways Agency implementing a 30mph zone through Chorleywood.

Why have the school council not employeed a scholl crossing?

As for signs they can be the standard school flashing lights that can positioned accordingly

Oh by the way I do know the road and school

Why cant a central island be built for the crossing control supervisor?

Sorry If I have offended but if I was involved I would want to heads to roll.

Does the MP have your full backing?

concerned parent of SCD, Chorleywood says...
3:34pm Wed 9 Jan 08

As I said before to A Friend (quite an inapproprite name really), All that could have been done over the years has been done. Dealing with councils is a nightmare. I wish you would refrain from making any more comments as you are going to upset all who read what you say. We have asked all of the same questions as you many times and got nowhere. If you think that makes us inadequate or failures for getting nothing done, fair enough. I can assure you that despite your big mouth, you would have acheived the same as us. The MP has been involved for the past 3 years and even he can't get this sorted. I know you are angry, as we all are but you are really not saying anything new. There are warning lights in place already and the speed of the van was not excessive which is why this student is still alive. Some of these kids are very small at age 11 and crossing the road is difficult for them. The fault lies squarely with the County Council who will take no action until there is an accident (their own words). We should remember that friends and family may read these comments and have heed of their feelings. You have said your piece now give it a rest please!

SCD Parent, Chorleywood says...
3:35pm Wed 9 Jan 08

Self evidently it should be a 30mph zone. That and all sorts of things could been done by the Highways Agency, including installing a light operated crossing. However, because there was yet to be an accident the Highways Agency rejected numerous approaches because of the lack of perceived risk.

You fail to grasp that neither the school nor the local residents have any control over the road.

Anyway, most people connected with the school are too upset to say anything right now. Myself included so this is my last posting.

But thanks for sharing your invaluable lobbying knowledge and experience.

A Friend, Bushey says...
3:46pm Wed 9 Jan 08

concerned parent of SCD wrote:
As I said before to A Friend (quite an inapproprite name really), All that could have been done over the years has been done. Dealing with councils is a nightmare. I wish you would refrain from making any more comments as you are going to upset all who read what you say. We have asked all of the same questions as you many times and got nowhere. If you think that makes us inadequate or failures for getting nothing done, fair enough. I can assure you that despite your big mouth, you would have acheived the same as us. The MP has been involved for the past 3 years and even he can't get this sorted. I know you are angry, as we all are but you are really not saying anything new. There are warning lights in place already and the speed of the van was not excessive which is why this student is still alive. Some of these kids are very small at age 11 and crossing the road is difficult for them. The fault lies squarely with the County Council who will take no action until there is an accident (their own words). We should remember that friends and family may read these comments and have heed of their feelings. You have said your piece now give it a rest please!
I take your point and apologize for any upset that I may have caused.

But the forum is there for comments as for "your big mouth" your words lets not get personal ah?

Dan, herts says...
4:57pm Wed 9 Jan 08

the person who said she only has herself to blame clearly does not know the girl.
And this 'Mike' seems to have a strong opinion about everyone elses life. the price of running a car is nothiing to do with this. what is is getting safer crossing and hoping she is ok.

Joce, Watford says...
4:57pm Wed 9 Jan 08

You are all pathetic. It was an accident. Get a life. Chloe get well soon. X

Luke, Loudwater says...
5:13pm Wed 9 Jan 08

Joce wrote:
You are all pathetic. It was an accident. Get a life. Chloe get well soon. X
It was an accident well spotted Joce - but could have been avoided with the intervention of Herts CC Highways!

Joce, Watford says...
5:17pm Wed 9 Jan 08

Luke. True, but it wasnt, complain about it to the highways agency, surely this page is for condolences.

James, says...
5:47pm Wed 9 Jan 08

i think that this is a huge wake up call to herts cc and scd school aswell, if the school allowed 6th form to park on the school property that would reduce a substantial amount of people crossing the road as parents could also use this area to drop children off. It is very clear now that 40mph is not a suitable speed limit for a road next to a school and some sort of crossing should be added. I think alot of people need to get a grip and think about what is important here the fact that a young girl has been seriously injoured and is still seriously ill and people need to find a way to stop this from ever happying again.

david cox, chorleywood says...
6:41pm Wed 9 Jan 08

All the postings here referring to carbon footprints, pandering parents driving children and mobile phones are missing the point, and offensively so. I live very close to the school. There are very, very few pupils who naturally need to cross the road here, unless they have walked the lanes from Sarratt (lethally dangerous) or live in one of a dozen or so houses, hence the lack of crossing point. The vast majority of "crossers" are sixth-formers parking at the head of North Hill (which itself is unsatisfactory, causing great churn to the verges). The school needs to find a small area where its 6th formers can park and obviate the need to cross at this point. This has been an obvious and significant risk, which should have been unacceptable to the school for some time and which the governors and local authority should have addressed. I have, by the way, helped campaign unsuccessfully for a crossing outside Royal Masonic School, just two miles down the same road where there are a great many pupils crossing the road. The CC refused, saying only after a death or multiple serious injuries could a crossing be justified (£50k). No doubt a well-placed speed camera nearby would self-fund itself and a crossing in a matter of months...enhanced safety can be achieved with a little thought and often little expense without resorting to haranguing users of the internal combustion engine. I do wish the young lady well in her recovery.

SCD Pupil, Chorleywood says...
7:22pm Wed 9 Jan 08

As a clement danes student, i can say how much of an impact this has had on all of us, we are all upset and every thought we have is with Chloe. However what makes us mad is the fact that the council regused to put a crossing in because its too expensive, but instead of costing money, its cost one of our peers. All of us are shocked and shooken up. First day back to school and this tragic incident happens. I just hope that Chloe is ok and she is in my thoughts as well as her family, what they are going through is not even imagineable.

Dave, Herts says...
7:48pm Wed 9 Jan 08

Question - what happened 7 years ago? Was there another accident?

Whilst this was a tragic event, without knowing any of the details of the accident, how can any of you make any comment as to who was to blame and what caused it?!


anon, Bucks says...
8:26pm Wed 9 Jan 08

Does anyone else find it chilling that a crossing can only be justified "after a death or multiple serious injuries"?It's absolutely dreadful. I hope the girl makes a speedy recovery, and thoughts go to the family.

alex, says...
8:32pm Wed 9 Jan 08

so concerned parent - what have you done to resolve this!

Have you contacted the local council?

Have you arrange a parents crossing go slow?

Have you done anything in the 7 years - NO clearly not!

Does the school have a board of govenors?

Children are being forced? Do something about it now or there will be futher accidents!

Demand a meeting with all relevant authorities oh no foregot somebody else can do that! Do something these are your children and our future.

in response to a friend last term the 6th form put a petition together with 200+ signatures and presented it to both the school govenors and the council. the response from the govenors was that the council would not put in a crossing but also stated that the council had stop the school building a 6th form car park which was planned for in the recent building works. the council did not respond even tho the petition was sent twice to both the transport office and the council offices.

finaly i would also like to remind you that a large proportion of scd pupils do not live in heats cc so do not have the power to vote for that council through no fault of their own.

if anyone wants to know what was in the letter covering the petition im happy to post it hear maby then the council might stop ignoring it.

Motorist, S.Oxhey says...
1:28am Thu 10 Jan 08

To A Friend in Bushey, just to let you know that I know of two people (not from S.Oxhey) I must quote, that have lost their driving licences due to drink driving after going out the night before so yes it does happen at 9am Chloe has now been transferred to the Royal Free in Hampstead. This is an excellent hospital, and Chloe will get the best treatment there. My thoughts are with you and your family.

Boris, Ricky says...
10:02am Thu 10 Jan 08

I drive past the school every morning on my work and have been reading these postings since the accident.
Although not a proper crossing at the entrance to the school there is a small island which to cross with some degree of safety. It appears that the kids ignore this as on my journey this morning two 6th formers crossed just 30m down from it and had to walk down the middle of the road whilst waiting for cars to pass and a gap in the traffic. No amount of crossings or speed cameras are going to help the situation here if the Pupils don't use the designated crossings. If with such an incident so fresh in their minds a crossing point is not utlised what hope is there a few months down the line, once the dust has settled

Andy, Chorleywood says...
12:57pm Thu 10 Jan 08

Boris - couldn't agree more, you are spot on. I also see this behaviour on an almost daily basis.

Zoe, Work says...
1:54pm Thu 10 Jan 08

Boris and Andy, I agree with what you have said. When I was a pupil at Rickmansworth School, most of the students (myself included, I must admit) totally ignored the crossing and chose to cross a little further down Scot's Hill, or at the bottom of the hill. To this day I still have no idea why, seeing as there was a perfectly good crossing, I guess kids just see using the crossing as boring or too parent-like.

Whilst this is definatley a problem amongst younger people, it still doesn't detract from the fact that a girl has been injured and without knowing the full facts, none of us can turn around and say "oh its the pedestrian's/driver'

s" fault. Its clear that something does need to be done here but blaming various sections of society is not the way to go about it.

I don't live in the area anymore but spent most of my lfe in Ricky and I am very aware of the dangers on that road, even when trying to pull out as a driver onto the main road from a side street etc. I can only hope that this doesn't happen to any one else, and I wish the girl involved all the best and a speedy recovery. A good thing to remember is to take care when crossing ANY road, whether its busy or not, and for motorists to be more aware of their surroundings and remember you don't have to do the maximum speed limit just because it's there.

anon, herts says...
4:32pm Thu 10 Jan 08

Lets be honest - thats not a real crossing is it - just a bit in the middle of the road for people to stop in. If a proper crossing was put in with warning signs displayed on approaching this then motorists would hopefully slow down. 40mph past a school is ridiculous - it should be 30 at a max. Students aren't being lazy/ignorant by not using that supposed crossing - that was where the accident happened.
Lets stop this pathetic debate.

Zoe, Work says...
4:58pm Thu 10 Jan 08

I was referring to the real crossing at Ricky school just to agree to a degree with the point that Boris made above, not to argue with anyone. I'm not trying to take away from the fact that the traffic does go far too fast past SCD either, just passing an observation of something that I too have been guilty of and I would imagine everyone has.

carly, chorleywood says...
7:37pm Thu 10 Jan 08

for all those who are arguing with eachother, i think the clearest thing to do would be to earn some justice for poor chloe and get that road sorted out or put in a crossing or something. There doesn't need to be a repeat of what's happened to chloe.
I hope she makes a full recovery.

Paul, C-wood says...
4:20pm Fri 11 Jan 08

Anon - "with warning signs displayed on approaching this then motorists would hopefully slow down."

Yeah, right! Since when do motorists obey ANY signs?! The only thing that slows motorists down is speed cameras - and then its only for the few meters in the camera's range.

However, speed does not kill - inappropriate speed does. (http://www.safespee
d.org.uk/)

Tom, chorleywood says...
5:09pm Fri 11 Jan 08

I would just like to pass my wishes to Chloe before i have a large rant at some of the people commenting on this story!

I am a student at clement danes and i know Chloe personally because i am/possibly spending a whole month of my summer holidays with her this year, as 3 groups from our school are going to tanzania.

There was a comment that i read earlier this week about girl, from my school, who got run over and killed 10 years ago when crossing the road. The parent who posted this comment obviously did not know that the child who got killed was not crossing Chorleywood Road coming into school but was run over after her ballet lesson. I think you should know that before you go and point the finger at people.

Also i would like to say that this was an accident and you cannot blame anyone for this. The council can possibly be blamed for it, but as you all know it is an A road and putting a zebra crossing there would be stupid. Admittedly there is an island just 30m down the road where students can cross, but to be honest its in the wrong place because the students who do park on the Sarratt side don't walk that way into school.

I am on the schools student council and i will be proposing that we ask the county council to build an under pass for the students to go under the road safely and effectively.

Although it is too late to have prevented Chloe's accident, we can still stop accidents from occurring in the future.

"if Chloe had been in year 7 she would have died", fellow student.

Chris Smith, Watford says...
10:58pm Fri 11 Jan 08

Maybe Clement Dane could use some of their field space as a carpark/drop off point to save this happening again. My thoughts are with the family and i wish their daughter a full recovery.

Chris Smith, Watford says...
10:59pm Fri 11 Jan 08

Maybe Clement Dane could use some of their field space as a carpark/drop off point to save this happening again. My thoughts are with the family and i wish their daughter a full recovery.

Paul, Bushey says...
5:57am Sat 12 Jan 08

Responce from Herts CC to my correspondance - Have received your email concerning the speed limit and crossing facility at Clements Danes School, We aware of the incident that occurred on Monday but to date have not had the full details from the police. The matter is being discussed by our member at Joint Members Panel on the 30 January at Three Rivers House. Consequently both of these issues will be discussed by the panel to determine whether any improvements are feasible at this location but this would have to be assessed against other traffic problem demands across the District, before funding can be sought.

scd parent, chorleywood says...
8:03pm Sun 13 Jan 08

SCD pupils walking along Green Street are no safer than those on the main road since the pavement is narrow, in poor condition and alongside a road with a 40+ mph limit for much of its length.

anon, herts says...
12:27pm Thu 17 Jan 08

in reply to anna rack with ref;to was the driver on a mobile phone at the time of the accident NO HE WAS NOT USING A MOBILE PHONE AT THE TIME.I also know the driver very well.The girl ran across the road and slipped on the wet road in front of the vechile,the vechile which could not avoid hitting her.All the comments are towards the injured girl.Nodody has made refernce to the poor driver who also has to live with the terriable accident for the rest of there life as well.

Peter, Chorleywood says...
1:37pm Sat 19 Jan 08

When I was at Clement Danes 20 years ago, no sixth formers had cars. Maybe one or two had motorbikes. In the past decade or so sixth formers have started to park along the triangle of land opposite the school.
Then risking their lives by crossing the Chorleywood Road A404 .

I would say that either Clement Danes should ban sixth formers from driving to school or expand their car park so that they can park within in the school's boundary.

They have essentially done nothing to resolve 'an accident waiting to happen' themselves.

parent, herts says...
8:33am Thu 24 Jan 08

anon wrote:
in reply to anna rack with ref;to was the driver on a mobile phone at the time of the accident NO HE WAS NOT USING A MOBILE PHONE AT THE TIME.I also know the driver very well.The girl ran across the road and slipped on the wet road in front of the vechile,the vechile which could not avoid hitting her.All the comments are towards the injured girl.Nodody has made refernce to the poor driver who also has to live with the terriable accident for the rest of there life as well.
without prejudice.
Were you at the scene of the accident? How come you are so sure of events?Unless you were your comments are unhelpful unless to the approriate authorities. I have no doubt that the driver will have to carry this around for the rest of his life. How do you think Our daughter and we, her family feel? Our 16 yr old beautiful, bright ,witty, popular,loving(to mention but a few words to describer Chloe)daughter has had her life turned in an instant.She is a fighter and will amaze as she has so far, but please don't think for even one moment that Chloe will not have to live with this, and the implications for the rest of her life.
I will take this opportunity to put a few facts abou other comments.

Chloe has a bus pass, but took a lift with a friend who was driving to Chorleywood Station.
North Hill is not an appropriate walking route and there is no footpath.
Chloe was not on her mobile phone. It was in her bag
Unhelpful cooments regarding the schools admission policy and several other ones in this comment section are being used as a forum to bring other unhelpful and unrelated issues to the fore. That having been said we are very grateful for all the messgaes of support for Chloe.

lion330, home says...
9:50pm Sat 26 Jan 08

I am the partner of the driver and he has hat to give up his job as he cannont drive pass where the accident happened,he is not a fast driver as i've been with him when he has been driving.

Comments are closed on this article.

Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »