Former teacher at Francis Combe School who swore at students found guilty of unprofessional conduct

A teacher at a Watford school, who swore at pupils, told one ginger haired boy to “stop being ginger” and compiled a “fit list” of teachers with one of his classes, has been spared punishment by his professional body.

The General Teaching Council’s Professional Conduct Committee found Nathan Woodville guilty of “unacceptable professional conduct” while employed at Francis Combe School as subject leader for geography.

However, it decided to impose no sanction, finding that he was a newly qualified teacher when he joined the school in 2007, and that he had re-established his professional reputation since joining Lea Valley High School in Enfield.

The Committee said that, on October 6 2008, Mr Woodville acted inappropriately and unprofessionally in compiling a "fit list" of teachers, with students. The findings say that the list was “derogatory to colleagues”.

The Committee also found that he compiled the list of attractive teachers with a Year 7 class, describing one colleague as having “a really good body". It rejected his claim that the list was actually a list of the class’ favourite teachers.

The findings also say that he “repeatedly used inappropriate language in front of students”, with pupils claiming he swore in front of them.

He admitted that he used inappropriate language in class, including, terms such as “you are pissing me off”, and words like “bloody” and “arse.”

However the Committee said it was not necessary to determine exactly which words he used, adding: “All are equally inappropriate.

It said that he also lost his temper with a Year 9 group of students, throwing and breaking a computer mouse, leaving his wallet on the table, telling the students his PIN number and then walking out of the classroom, and made a derogatory comment to a student about the colour of his hair.

Mr Woodville admitted saying to the boy: “Sit down and stop being ginger”.

The findings say he also made inappropriate comments to a member of staff about their sexuality at a school social function.

Committee chair Kim Tyrell said: “As Mr Woodville himself has accepted when giving evidence, his conduct was entirely inappropriate and unprofessional. By behaving as he did he not only brought the profession into disrepute but also failed to afford proper respect to his pupils and colleagues.

“The misconduct which brought Mr Woodville before the Committee is undoubtedly serious. His actions had the potential to damage not only his own reputation but also the reputations of his school and the profession at large and to adversely affect pupil development.

“However, the Committee accepts that Mr Woodville was placed in a difficult and stressful situation by his appointment as subject leader in his first year as a fully qualified teacher.

“From the outset, Mr Woodville has admitted that his misconduct was entirely inappropriate and unprofessional and reflected poorly not only on himself but on the teaching profession as a whole. He has shown insight into his failures and has expressed remorse for them.

“The Committee is left in no doubt that he has learned from his mistakes and is now a far more mature individual who is most unlikely to repeat his mistakes.”

She said that, in the three years since moving on from Francis Combe School, he had “re-established his professional reputation in the classroom” and had organised charity events which served to enhance the reputation of the teaching profession in the eyes of the public.

She added: “That being so, the Committee has concluded that this is a case which does not require it to impose a sanction. In the exceptional circumstances of this case, the finding of unacceptable professional conduct alone is sufficient to set and maintain proper standards of conduct and behaviour and adequately protect the reputation of the teaching profession.”

Mr Woodville has the right of appeal to High Court within 28 days.

Comments(15)

Andy O'Brien says...
12:31pm Tue 13 Dec 11

Wonder what he would have acted in the classroom 30 or 40 years ago?
Beat them up?

"Fit list" for year 7...that is too much thats 11-12 year olds!

I doubt if he will appeal he has got off lightly in my opinion.

luther blissett says...
12:39pm Tue 13 Dec 11

Why would appeal when there is no punishment in the first place?

RookeryHorn says...
12:54pm Tue 13 Dec 11

Andy O'Brien, it says he made a fit list of TEACHERS, not year 7 students, otherwise we'd be reading a very different story.

MrFlash says...
1:03pm Tue 13 Dec 11

"Stop being Ginger", excellent. I know that everybody reading this article has heard and seen a lot worse when they were at school.

I'm struggling to see the problem.

Furthermore, have you stopped to think that certain "children" are near on impossible to teach and need a slightly stronger line?

MrFlash says...
1:13pm Tue 13 Dec 11

Andy O'Brien says...
12:31pm Tue 13 Dec 11

Wonder what he would have acted in the classroom 30 or 40 years ago?
Beat them up?

"Fit list" for year 7...that is too much thats 11-12 year olds!

-----------

Bit of an overreaction here. Should probably try reading it properly too.

John Howard Norfolk says...
4:45pm Tue 13 Dec 11

Actually this could well be just the sort of teacher who will be remembered and respected in years to come by his students. What really matters is that his classes deliver sound teaching!

Andy O'Brien says...
5:10pm Tue 13 Dec 11

I wouldn't say I was overreacting....but you can be overfamiliar.

I never queried his teaching ability.

To my other detractors you read the article "compiled with year 7 pupils"

Andy O'Brien says...
5:15pm Tue 13 Dec 11

luther blissett wrote:
Why would appeal when there is no punishment in the first place?
fair point "luther"

WatfordV123 says...
8:57pm Tue 13 Dec 11

I think this is silly. He was a very good teacher and always kept the kids occupied and taught what he was supposed to be teaching, and classes didn't fall behind. So what if he got angry once or slipped out a 'swear word'? He's human, everyone has bad days, its not like he was screaming in any kids faces, no big deal; he was lovely.

Bone123 says...
9:51pm Tue 13 Dec 11

This is stupid he was a great teacher even if he was a bit of a idiot atleast he managed to teach us sonething
And after he was gone we were stuck with rubbish teachers and subs that taught us nothing at all!!! so what was the point? If you kept him kids would still be learning and havibg fun at the same timr

John Howard Norfolk says...
9:53pm Tue 13 Dec 11

WatfordV123 wrote:
I think this is silly. He was a very good teacher and always kept the kids occupied and taught what he was supposed to be teaching, and classes didn't fall behind. So what if he got angry once or slipped out a 'swear word'? He's human, everyone has bad days, its not like he was screaming in any kids faces, no big deal; he was lovely.
Too right - the best Maths teacher I had at Pinner Grammar would throw chalk at us. If he lost patience and temper with our questions and inability to understand he simply wrote three words on the blackboard:

USE YOUR LOAF !

Mr J B ("Dan") Leno I salute you and I remember your excellent Maths lessons of the 1950's.

The-tiny-panda says...
10:20pm Tue 13 Dec 11

I actually had him as a teacher when I was like in year 8 and I dont remember him being like this at all. I remember he was one of the really nice teachers and everyone liked him....... Just goes to show

nikkiw says...
9:19am Wed 14 Dec 11

I wouldn’t want to be a teacher in this day and age for no amount of money. What kids get away with is ridiculous. Teachers have to walk on eggshells and watch every word, but pupils can run riots. When my own daughter misbehaved at school recently I asked teachers to discipline her but I was told they weren’t allowed to do or say any of the things I suggested, as they'd be the ones in trouble. In other words, my daughter could do more or less as she pleased and their hands were tied. So is it any wonder that some of them eventually snap? I think the ginger comment was out of order but I’m not particularly fussed about the rest. I had some excellent teachers who weren't exactly politically correct and they were the best.

not a regular says...
3:26pm Wed 14 Dec 11

Sounds like an awesome teacher! You can bet I learned more from that type of educator (funny, on the same wavelength as the pupils) than the ones that can't be arsed or go on a power trip.

nikkiw says...
4:03pm Wed 14 Dec 11

Are you taking notes Teaching Council Committe? Leave the man alone and spend your money and time on something useful next time.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree