Allotment holders concerned over future of plots (From Watford Observer)
Get involved: send your pictures, video, news and views by texting WO to 80360, or email us
West Watford allotments considered as part of Health Campus development
10:28am Tuesday 19th June 2012 in News
By Mike Wright, Chief Reporter
Allotment holders in West Watford vented their anger after learning their plots may be lost in the Health Campus development.
Watford’s elected mayor, Dorothy Thornhill face heated questioning from residents at a meeting last night as the council agreed to look at letting developers use Farm Terrace allotments as part of the £1bn scheme.
Allotment holders were sent letters last week saying their plots were now to be considered as part of the scheme after originally being protected due to the worsening economic climate.
The Health Campus project promises to redevelop the land around Watford General Hospital, with a new hospital as well as new homes and leisure facilities.
The move comes as Watford Borough Council is in crunch negotiations with two developers over which of them will get the final contract.
At a meeting of the council’s Liberal Democrat cabinet last night, which was well attended by allotment holders, councillors and the mayor voted to look at options including using all the Farm Terrace land, half or none of it.
Before the vote the mayor addressed the allotment holders, saying nothing had been decided over the Farm Terrace land and they would be fully consulted over any changes.
Dorothy Thornhill said: "At the moment as it is at a very early stage which may take years. I have done you the courtesy of telling you that things have changed from what you understand."
When pressed on why the allotments were now being considered for development, the mayor said she did not know the exact specifics.
However she told allotment holders her understanding was that the Farm Terrace land could be crucial to the whole Health Campus being a viable prospect for developers.
"My understanding is that it is in order to make the whole package stand up," said Mayor Thornhill.
"They are (the developers) taking a massive risk. I know we like to paint the developers as the bad guys."
In a report to the cabinet on the progress on the Health Campus officers said the tough economic climate had not helped the project by two tranches of funding totalling £13m had boosted the project.
Yet councillors were told the inclusion of the allotment site could be crucial for the viability of the scheme.
The report said: "Without the inclusion of some of the allotment site, delivery would be very much more difficult and the end result far less advantageous from the perspective of providing a new quarter for this area of West Watford.
"Viability would be impacted. As members are aware there are also pressures to provide other community assets such as a primary school.
"Utilising a significant portion of the allotments will greatly assist to develop a viable and better masterplan."
Following the meeting Watford Borough Council shed more light on why the allotments may need to be used in the Health Campus.
Among the reasons developers have given for why they may need the land are in case the hospital needs to be expanded beyond what it is currently planned.
Developers are also facing a more than £30m costs to clear the site of waste, build a bridge over the railway, level the land for building and put in flood prevention measures.
Therefore the companies vying for the Health Campus contract have said they may need the extra land to offset the mounting costs of the project.
The allotment land has also been mooted as a site for a new primary school.
Comments(15)
gusgreen
says...
11:30am Tue 19 Jun 12
TRT
says...
11:49am Tue 19 Jun 12
crazyfrog
says...
12:51pm Tue 19 Jun 12
TRT
says...
1:09pm Tue 19 Jun 12
Reg Edit
says...
2:14pm Tue 19 Jun 12
Developers can never have enough profit and the council are either so corrupt or so stupid as to let this happen. Is anyone on the council getting anything out of this? If not, what on earth is driving this change to the plans?
Dotty says it is so "The project can stand up". That is woolly and typical of Liberal speak.
Give facts Dotty, tell the people why you are taking away this valuable green resource. Be honest with the people of Watford, after all, you and every other council worker work for us.
Useless Liberal windmills 1 (pretending to be green), Green land (which is actually green) 0.
The whole thing smells bad. This needs an enquiry if it goes ahead.
TRT
says...
2:36pm Tue 19 Jun 12
The Rover
says...
3:12pm Tue 19 Jun 12
Reg Edit wrote:More housing = more income from Council Tax. As far as the council are concerned they can make more money from housing than they can from an allotment.
More land = more housing = more profit.
Developers can never have enough profit and the council are either so corrupt or so stupid as to let this happen. Is anyone on the council getting anything out of this? If not, what on earth is driving this change to the plans?
Dotty says it is so "The project can stand up". That is woolly and typical of Liberal speak.
Give facts Dotty, tell the people why you are taking away this valuable green resource. Be honest with the people of Watford, after all, you and every other council worker work for us.
Useless Liberal windmills 1 (pretending to be green), Green land (which is actually green) 0.
The whole thing smells bad. This needs an enquiry if it goes ahead.
scarecrow
says...
9:11pm Tue 19 Jun 12
"RUBBISH"
drunkenduck
says...
10:14pm Tue 19 Jun 12
The Rover wrote:Because Fib Debs let so many developers build more homes, to able to keep the council tax low. Even at the cost of losing green belts, parks, allotments etc.
Reg Edit wrote:More housing = more income from Council Tax. As far as the council are concerned they can make more money from housing than they can from an allotment.
More land = more housing = more profit.
Developers can never have enough profit and the council are either so corrupt or so stupid as to let this happen. Is anyone on the council getting anything out of this? If not, what on earth is driving this change to the plans?
Dotty says it is so "The project can stand up". That is woolly and typical of Liberal speak.
Give facts Dotty, tell the people why you are taking away this valuable green resource. Be honest with the people of Watford, after all, you and every other council worker work for us.
Useless Liberal windmills 1 (pretending to be green), Green land (which is actually green) 0.
The whole thing smells bad. This needs an enquiry if it goes ahead.
So Dotty wants to cover the allotments with tons of concrete to get a vote! Think she's one of the "bad guys" here too, not just the developers. Speaking to many health professions at the hospital, they ware surprise that one billion pounds is getting spent to cover the cost of this Health Campus development. Many believe the money has not been spent wisely of redeveloping the hospital but instead it's gone somewhere else - i.e. someone's pocket.
And why is the developers moaning about spending more money, £30 million. After all they're getting nearly one billion pounds of tax payers money.
But who's next and shame the Liberal Democrat and/or councillors for anyone who votes for this and the mayor to replace a sustainable land for more houses and part campus. It be Cassiobury Park be next, under attack to be built on by the council.
Reg Edit
says...
8:26am Wed 20 Jun 12
Sorry, I can't type any more, I hurt myself from laughing so much...
TRT
says...
2:01pm Wed 20 Jun 12
But you know what'll happen when it gets down to it? they'll offer an unfinished generic space to the county who will suddenly find it to be an unsuitable site for a school, and it will end up as a commercial development with, at best, a private pre-school nursery with space for 8 kids.
Reg Edit
says...
9:48am Thu 21 Jun 12
you seem to make a good point. The whole thing seems fishy.
TRT
says...
10:48am Thu 21 Jun 12
Were we or were we not promised a bowling alley and/or cinema as part of the Harlequin development? And what did we get? They gave the council some money instead and the leisure facility got built miles out of town with next to no public transport, and the lower half of the high street turns into a mugger's paradise as soon as the shutters come down, while the top end of town becomes binge-drinker city. Domino effect.
worzle
says...
5:07pm Thu 21 Jun 12
TRT says...
10:55am Tue 19 Jun 12
*sarcasm on* Of course, growing your own fresh food, getting fresh air and exercise is nothing to do with an integrated health policy. *sarcasm off*
Despicable turn of affairs that a project so long in the planning suddenly gets the viability heebie-jeebies. Just like Croxly Rail Link and the Met closure... and I bet this will happen with Morrisson's too and the playing fields at the back - they need a new road perhaps? Paint the developers as the bad guys? Well if the safety cap fits...