Barnsley loss makes it back-to-back league defeats for very poor Watford

Gianfranco Zola on the touchline at Oakwell. Picture: Action Images Gianfranco Zola on the touchline at Oakwell. Picture: Action Images

A very poor Watford display got what it deserved at Barnsley as the hosts boosted their survival prospects with a 1-0 win and Gianfranco Zola’s men again missed the opportunity to climb back into the top two.

Watford were shaky at the back, poor in possession and struggled creatively in a very disappointing first-half display and could have no complaints at being behind at the break to a header from early substitute Bobby Hassell.

Despite making changes, the Hornets didn’t improve after the break against the hosts’ well utilised pressing game and one Matej Vydra snap-shot at Luke Steele aside, they never seriously looked like equalising.

With Hull City losing at home to Nottingham Forest, three points would have taken the Hornets back up to second. Instead, they head into the final international break of the season on the back of suffering back-to-back league defeats for the first time since October.

The Tykes though, deserve considerable credit for the manner in which they gained the win. Watford were never allowed to get their passing going as the home side pressed and battled for everything throughout.

Zola made three changes as the Hornets sought to get back on track following last week’s defeat at home to Blackpool. Joel Ekstrand, Marco Cassetti and Vydra were all back in the starting line-up as Daniel Pudil and Fernando Forestieri dropped to a bench that also included the fit-again Fitz Hall and Nathaniel Chalobah, but Matthew Briggs was ruled out through injury.

The match was also significant for Lloyd Doyley, who made his 398th Watford appearance and moved up to joint tenth on the club’s all-time appearance list alongside Ross Jenkins.

Barnsley were unchanged from the side which picked up a 2-1 win over Brighton & Hove Albion to record their first victory in five attempts in all competitions.

It was the home side who had the first attempt of the afternoon in the second minute when they were awarded a free-kick just over 25 yards out but Tom Kennedy’s left-footed strike cleared the crossbar by a couple of feet.

Watford though, posed a greater threat two minutes later when Cassetti played the ball in to Troy Deeney, who tried to let it run for Vydra but it broke to Jonathan Hogg to find Ikechi Anya in space on the left side of the area. He cut inside and saw his right-footed shot almost deflected through to Deeney, but the ball was scrambled away to Hogg, who returned it goal-bound with his head and keeper Steele managed to scramble it away under pressure from Deeeny.

The Tykes suffered a blow in the sixth minute when right-back Rory Delap was forced to make an early exit through injury and was replaced by Hassell. Generally though, the hosts had made the better start and their pressing game was not allowing the Hornets to get into their usual passing rhythm.

The hosts continued to force the issue and it took some smart defending from Doyley to prevent Jason Scotland having a golden opening before Chris O’Grady crossed from the left and Jim O’Brien tried to head back into the danger zone from beyond the far post but Jonathan Bond was able to gather.

Ekstrand could have few complaints about receiving the game’s first yellow card in the 18th minute for a clear body check on O’Brien. But the booking count was levelled up within four minutes when Hassell was cautioned for a trip on Anya, although referee Tony Bates did play the advantage as the Hornets wide man was able to stay on his feet to keep an attack going before it broke down.

Hassell fired over from distance as the midway point of the opening period passed and then Vydra missed the target at the other end with a snap-shot on the turn after Cassetti laid the ball back to him following a Mark Yeates pass. However, the move had originally been started on the left flank with a searing 60-yard burst from Anya, who took on O’Brien and then Hassell and left them both trailing in his wake.

Bond came to his side’s rescue in the 34th minute with a smart stop to deny Scotland after he had been set clear by Jacob Mellis’ reverse pass. But the home side were to make the most of their next opportunity less than a minute later.

David Flitcroft’s side were awarded a free-kick to the left of centre midway inside the Hornets’ half and Mellis’ delivery towards the far post was thumped home by the head of Hassell to make it 1-0.

Watford had been poor until this point but they almost created an opening two minutes before the interval when Deeney dispossessed David Perkins on halfway and immediately lifted the ball into the path of Vydra, but the on-rushing Steele read the danger and managed to clear just before the Hornets’ top scorer could nick the ball past him.

But it was to be the hosts who had the final opportunity of the half when O’Brien’s cross from the right was headed over by O’Grady as Barnsley deservedly went into the break a goal to the good.

There was no surprise that Zola made a change at the start of the second half, with Chalobah coming on for the disappointing Yeates. Barnsley also made a substitution at the interval, with Chris Dagnall replacing Scotland.

Both sides had early attacking opportunities after the break but it was Bond who was again called into the action in the 53rd minute when he did well to divert O’Grady’s powerful left-footed angled shot over the bar.

Flitcroft played his final card in the 57th minute when Tomasz Cywka came on for Mellis, while Deeney was yellow-carded shortly after for catching Steele with a late raised boot.

The Hornets had still not got into the stride as the hour-mark passed, prompting Zola to turn to his bench as Hogg and Anya made way for Geoffrey Mujangi Bia and Fernando Forestieri.

Both substitutes had shots blocked moments after entering the fray as the Hornets finally sought to get some attacking urgency into their play but their efforts continued to be sporadic, although they were enjoying a greater share of possession and territory.

Perkins saw yellow for a foul on Forestieri in the 70th minute but two minutes later came Watford’s best chance to date when Deeney attempted to flick on Cristian Battocchio’s cross from the right and Scott Wiseman’s attempted clearance fell straight to Vydra on the edge of the area. He connected well enough with a right-footed half-volley but the strike was pretty much straight at Steele.

The card count rose to five in the 75th minute when Wiseman was cautioned after catching Doyley then and then Mujangi Bia and Forestieri both had crossing opportunities from the left side of the Barnsley box but on both occasions their driven efforts were repelled.

The situation was now starting to get a little desperate for the Hornets and they were fortunate it was not game over in the 84th minute when O’Grady released Dagnall through the middle, but the Barnsley striker fired over the bar with only Bond to beat.

O’Grady had an opening of his own four minutes later but he rather toe-poked at the ball from the left side of the area and Bond was able to comfortably save.

Mujangi Bia fired over from long range at the other end but despite there being four minutes of injury time, the Hornets were unable to create another opportunity until the very last minute when a corner from the left was played back into the danger zone by Ekstrand and Deeney nearly seized on Forestieri’s overhead kick before the ball was scrambled behind.

Following the resultant set piece, the ball broke to Battocchio but his shot from outside the area was blocked as the Hornets were beaten for the second match in succession.

Barnsley: Steele; Delap (Hassell 6), Wiseman, Cranie, Kennedy; O’Brien, Etuhu, Perkins, Mellis (Cywka 57); O’Grady, Scotland (Dagnall 46). Not used: Dawson, Alnwick, Harewood and Tunnicliffe.

Watford: Bond; Doyley, Nosworthy, Ekstrand; Cassetti, Battocchio, Yeates (Chalobah 46), Hogg (Mujangi Bia 62), Anya (Forestieri 62); Deeney, Vydra. Not used: Hall, Pudil, Bonham and Geijo.

Bookings: Ekstrand for a foul on O’Brien (18); Hassell for a foul on Anya (22); Deeney for a foul on Steele (59); Perkins for a foul on Forestieri (70); Wiseman for a foul on Doyley (75).

Attendance: 9,076 (1,074 away).

Referee: Tony Bates.

Comments(33)

jasonwatford says...
5:21pm Sat 16 Mar 13

time to sit down...take a blow and get back to doing the basics....If NC is carrying a knock you play your best team from start and if he needs to come off he comes off not the other way round.

Marcofan says...
5:21pm Sat 16 Mar 13

What a load of crap that was, lucky on this form to make the playoffs, shows how much we rely on abdi

jalvin says...
5:25pm Sat 16 Mar 13

Oh well could be worse.

peter10531089 says...
5:30pm Sat 16 Mar 13

jasonwatford wrote:
time to sit down...take a blow and get back to doing the basics....If NC is carrying a knock you play your best team from start and if he needs to come off he comes off not the other way round.
Completely agree with this. Zola now has to really earn his money and get us firing again - Burnley now a truly massive game to create some momentum before Hull and Cardiff!

Come on you seagulls for tomorrow

Guy Bov says...
5:37pm Sat 16 Mar 13

International break couldn't have come at a better time. Need Abdi and Chalobah to be fit for the run in and Deeney and Vydra to start firing again.
A central midfielder from the loan market could be handy too.

stevyweavy says...
5:40pm Sat 16 Mar 13

Just re-enforces the fact how poor our midfield is without Abdi. As soon as I saw the midfield thought it would be a bad game for us. You can play any one of those three with Abdi & Chalobah but if you have to play two or more we always struggle. If the midfield are not working then it makes our defence and strike force look worse. If we are to have any chance of making one of the two top spots Abdi has to be fit and playing for the rest of the season. Only saving grace for today was that Hull ended up losing. On paper March should have been our month for pushing for top spot with April being the crunch month but now we have managed to put a really steep hill in front of us. Lets hope we are up to it!

weeblehorn says...
5:41pm Sat 16 Mar 13

Every time Hog and Yeates start i wish i had waited before i had put my money on Watford to win.

Mohandas says...
5:44pm Sat 16 Mar 13

Focus on what its in front. At this time every team especially at the bottom are going to give it their best shot. We need greater binding, greater passion, and greater ambition.

J.A.A. says...
5:45pm Sat 16 Mar 13

Looks like the wheels have come off ! We desperately need the A.A. ( Almen Abdi ).

a1derek says...
6:08pm Sat 16 Mar 13

I have said before Hogg and Yeates are simply not good enough in central midfield if our aspirations are promotion this season. Just look at the correlation of points won when they play together it's very plain and obvious. GFZ needs to take that on board. Results have pretty much gone "our way" in the last few weeks and we have contrived to "blow it" big time.

It's really only Forest on the charge at the moment everyone else is faltering. Thankfully we now have the international break and it does give us the chance to get everyone fit and indeed, this is definitely where GFZ earns his money. We must come out firing on all cylinders for Burnley.

OliverF1976 says...
6:34pm Sat 16 Mar 13

peter10531089 wrote:
jasonwatford wrote:
time to sit down...take a blow and get back to doing the basics....If NC is carrying a knock you play your best team from start and if he needs to come off he comes off not the other way round.
Completely agree with this. Zola now has to really earn his money and get us firing again - Burnley now a truly massive game to create some momentum before Hull and Cardiff!

Come on you seagulls for tomorrow
Unfortunately having been injured he has been back with Chelsea and as with all their loan players they dictate whether they play or not and it was out of Zolas hands. I'm sure he will play for England and pick up a knock though!

OliverF1976 says...
6:35pm Sat 16 Mar 13

Starting line up for the run in has to be if fit
Almunia
Doyley
Hall
Ekstrand
Cassetti
Abdi
Chalobah
Batocchio
Pudil
Deeney
Vydra

MJ1 says...
7:01pm Sat 16 Mar 13

Give some credit to the opposition. What has happened is that managers have sussed us out. Blackpool worked out that they had to stifle our passing game. They were in our faces and the same today with Barnsley. Our shape is not helped by regular team changes/rotation. GFZ needs a Plan B.

YoKsHiRe.....HoRn!!!!!!! says...
7:02pm Sat 16 Mar 13

Worst performance I've seen in a long time, Yeates was awful and the rest of the team weren't far behind him! Bond was our best player by far.

Fair play to Barnsley for doing their homework as we didn't have any time on the ball and were out muscled to every ball.

No plan B, why we didn't change our formation when we bought our last two subs on with half and hour to go is beyond me. Thank god we have two weeks to re group!

at least evryone around us is dropping points too, Onwards and COYH

KeithMercer says...
7:34pm Sat 16 Mar 13

YEATES STARTS = WATFORD LOSE !!
Please dont come on here and tell me he was Watfords best player in the first half last week.
The guy plays for himself, always has done always will do! thats why he has been let go by teams a lot worse than us. Dont hold him solely responsible for todays debacle but just look at the stats when he has started this season.

WessexLad says...
7:41pm Sat 16 Mar 13

It doesn't matter how good they are as footballers, if you play three midgets in central midfield, you're not going to win the midfield battle. Especially against a physical, in-you-face team like Barnsley. Didn't anyone watch the Brighton game?

Could we at least try Cassetti in the middle, with Anya on the right and Pudil on the left?

Well done to over 1000 away supporters.

Holly68 says...
7:50pm Sat 16 Mar 13

Midfield Shocking

Worst performance for months

Despite 30+ players, we now know who our strongest 11 are, and unfortuneatly some of this injured or playing carrying knocks ! Rest not good enough

V disappointed

HOWEVER

8 games to go, still all to play for ....

SAHornet says...
8:11pm Sat 16 Mar 13

We've ridden our luck in the last few games as far as other results have gone and again today. If Palarse turn over The Naughty Nigels tomoz then we slip to 4th. I'm really starting to s**t myself now. Keith, I heard you loud and clear today on Hornets Player. Shame the team didn't respond. We had more than 10% of the ground. Well done to all that travelled.Sorry it didn't turn out.

llloydwithathirdl says...
8:57pm Sat 16 Mar 13

OliverF1976 wrote:
Starting line up for the run in has to be if fit
Almunia
Doyley
Hall
Ekstrand
Cassetti
Abdi
Chalobah
Batocchio
Pudil
Deeney
Vydra
If it is we will go up.

Bad day at the office today, but Barnsley were also very good. Hopefully the break will help us recharge batteries.

There was only one Scully says...
9:54pm Sat 16 Mar 13

We were totally out played in many areas today. Yeats, was poor along with Battachio. Despite the idiot critics on here Hogg was the best of midfield. Up front Troy battled and again Vydra yes him, was disappointing, I really think his game has dropped and he is not performing.
On current form so far, we are faltering and not looking like the side we were a few weeks ago. Missing AA possibly. Time will tell if we can make the auto's but its a play off position I believe were we will be at the end of season. I hope!

HunsburyHornet says...
10:36pm Sat 16 Mar 13

MJ1 wrote:
Give some credit to the opposition. What has happened is that managers have sussed us out. Blackpool worked out that they had to stifle our passing game. They were in our faces and the same today with Barnsley. Our shape is not helped by regular team changes/rotation. GFZ needs a Plan B.
Excellent post. Spot on. We've been sussed.

Vet_kills_puppy says...
11:05pm Sat 16 Mar 13

Sorry Scully, but if Hogg on that showing was the best midfielder I'm off to Specsavers first thing Monday morning.
Apart from Anya and Bond the lot of them want bringing in for extra training in the pis*ing down rain tomorrow.
Not one of them was up for the fight that Barnsley brought onto the pitch.
What a crying shame when the pre-match atmosphere was so good.
Absolutely shocking performance.
And why the hell were some of you clapping them of the pitch at the end?
They didn't deserve a round of toast today let alone a round of applause.

Henry VIII says...
11:10pm Sat 16 Mar 13

Another dissapointing performance and result.One thing that has crept into sports summaries over the past few years is to look for the positives during the bad, I don't always agree with that if I am honest, but funnily enough I do still see a few positives. The first big thing is the international break, some of our payers may or may not be involved, but it will also allow for recovery and re-grouping. We haven't been playing well of late and I just hope that at this time we are still third and still to a very large part in control of our own destiny. There will still be a few twists to come, but we have to take care of our own and not worry about the others. Well done to Barnsley, I thuoght they looked decent enough in their cup run. Come on GFZ, one and all... it's still there for us :)

watford1881 says...
11:45pm Sat 16 Mar 13

llloydwithathirdl wrote:
OliverF1976 wrote:
Starting line up for the run in has to be if fit
Almunia
Doyley
Hall
Ekstrand
Cassetti
Abdi
Chalobah
Batocchio
Pudil
Deeney
Vydra
If it is we will go up.

Bad day at the office today, but Barnsley were also very good. Hopefully the break will help us recharge batteries.
The problem is a load of our players wont have a rest because of playing for national teams.. We still have a great chance of second.. Hull lost.. Palace might lose there Derby.. Plus we still have Hull, Leicester & Cardiff to play.. Chin up fans it's not all bad.. Remember where we have come from in such a short space of time...

The Not-so-enlightened one says...
8:28am Sun 17 Mar 13

Whinge, whinge, moan, moan. FFS we're still third - you'd have bitten my hand, arm and shoulder off if I'd offered you this in August. A manager and team still learning, but no, we've got to go up as Champions and 10 points clear at that. Get a grip.

lewisthegloryhorn says...
8:32am Sun 17 Mar 13

Why is the common view that Almunia should be back in as soon as he is fit? I think Bond has been our best player in the last 4 games, minus the mistakes which arguably weren't entirely his fault anyway. Along with that, there is nothing to panic about. A few of our players are definitely carrying knocks, and the break will put end to that. Abdi and Chalobah will come back in, and we will give a big push for automatic. We need to stop acting like the world has ended, things will pick up again.

Keith Eddy says...
10:05am Sun 17 Mar 13

I see that again when we lose some people put this down to Yeats & Hogg. Sorry this is nonsense this was a very poor team performance against a Barnsley side who wanted it more than us.

We do miss Abdi but we have enough quality to still win without him. We didn't earn the right to play yesterday and if you don't do that you will get beaten no matter who's on the pitch.

Not sure if Anya was injured & had to go off ? otherwise I would have taken Vydra off who clearly needs a rest and put Forestieri along side Deeney.

Still believe we can get automatic but we may have to get 20 points to do it. That's a tough ask but hey this has got to be better than just aiming for 53 points and safety every season.

@ChrisBottom16 says...
2:29pm Sun 17 Mar 13

Before everyone loses the plot completely, let's just take a step back and think about a few thing's...

This season was never intended for us to go up. This season was designed for the Pozzo's and Zola to come in, Reduce the debt, discover which player's aren't good enough, Develop a playing style, ethos for the club and bring in a backbone of player's that will stay long term and provide the platform to build on in the summer.

So far in my mind we are on target with what the owner's and management were expecting from this season.

We have devloped a playing style, The club has a new ethos and identitiy, they have reduced if not cleared the debt and provided us with the player's who are now the backbone of the team and who we can build on in the summer!

Next season was alway's going to be season when we went hard for promotion.

Let's take a reality check and stop actin like spoilt little girl's and enjoy the rest of the season regardless of what happen's, in the knowledge that we are on course and only great time's lay ahead!

kingofpop says...
5:45pm Sun 17 Mar 13

I think its normal to be disappointed when the team have not been at the races lately. Many people are correct in the thinking we lack a plan b which i think is spot on, but also the awful subs he makes, 95% of the time they are ineffective yet palace, wolves and blackpool have benefited from good subs at the right time. Still not totally convinced we have players for the formation, mainly the wing backs but also we have a real lack of physical presence in midfield, even the current back 3 are'nt big...lots for zola to do still.

Mohandas says...
7:27pm Sun 17 Mar 13

jalvin wrote:
Oh well could be worse.
Brighton 3
Crystal Palace 0
Have faith.

OliverF1976 says...
8:17am Mon 18 Mar 13

lewisthegloryhorn wrote:
Why is the common view that Almunia should be back in as soon as he is fit? I think Bond has been our best player in the last 4 games, minus the mistakes which arguably weren't entirely his fault anyway. Along with that, there is nothing to panic about. A few of our players are definitely carrying knocks, and the break will put end to that. Abdi and Chalobah will come back in, and we will give a big push for automatic. We need to stop acting like the world has ended, things will pick up again.
Bond has done great but I think it is very important to have experience at the back at this point of the season. Almunia has been excellent and his communication and distribution from the back was invaluable during our most successful period of the season. Don't get me wrong it won't be the end of the world to have bond in but if Almunia is fit then he has to start, he is a premier league keeper. Bonds howler against Blackpool seems to have been swept under the carpet but he is young and will be a fantastic keeper for us

OliverF1976 says...
8:22am Mon 18 Mar 13

Keith Eddy wrote:
I see that again when we lose some people put this down to Yeats & Hogg. Sorry this is nonsense this was a very poor team performance against a Barnsley side who wanted it more than us.

We do miss Abdi but we have enough quality to still win without him. We didn't earn the right to play yesterday and if you don't do that you will get beaten no matter who's on the pitch.

Not sure if Anya was injured & had to go off ? otherwise I would have taken Vydra off who clearly needs a rest and put Forestieri along side Deeney.

Still believe we can get automatic but we may have to get 20 points to do it. That's a tough ask but hey this has got to be better than just aiming for 53 points and safety every season.
Oh come on the facts are there for all to see. The central midfield is so important to our team and the way we play and the central midfield is where the fight begins and those two just were not up to it. Once we get our full strength back they will not start another game for us which says it all. We can get away with Hogg being in there with Abdi and Chalobah but without those two particularly Abdi it is just obvious they don't have the quality the a promotion chasing team require

tiger bay says...
5:16pm Mon 18 Mar 13

OK...lets get one thing straight.... Barnsley were POOR!!! They were basic, determined and aggressive but were there for the taking.. Only Ekstrand and Big Nyron performed at acceptable levels, the rest were shocking. Battochio had the worst performance in a Watford midfield shirt since the year dot and was a very lucky boy to not be taken off. Lets not pretend it was a bad day at the office as we havn't really performed well since the Huddersfield game,,and before you all shout 'Birmingham' away!! Anyone who was there will tell u the scoreline flattered us.. Almunia is missed..Bond has great potential but needs to be taken out of the firing line as the opposition has identified a weakness and are continually putting high balls and pressure onto him...Abdi's ball retention is badly missed too...we can't all be wrong, there was an air of pessimism among the 1000 of us in Oakwell when the teamsheet was read out..Zola is allowed a learning curve like everyone else but now MUST play the strongest 11 from the outset and if we pick up injuries so be it..thats part and parcel of football. Great time for the international break, now we will see if Zola is the real deal or not...

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree