Sport RSS Feed


Hornets v Town Banner

Watford to decide whether to report Reading to Football League


Watford will decide today (Friday) if they will report Reading to the Football League after former manager Brendan Rodgers’ comments that Hornets’ talisman Tommy Smith wants to join him at the Madejski Stadium.

In a press conference on Wednesday, Rodgers, who became Royals’ boss on June 4, stated he would love to sign Smith and that the forward also wants to play for him once more.

However, Reading have not submitted another bid since last week’s £750,000 offer was rejected and described as “derisory” by Watford chairman Jimmy Russo.

Both Russo and Rodgers’ replacement Malky Mackay have questioned how Reading would know of Smith’s plans as it is against Football League rules to speak to a player under contract without his parent club’s permission.

Yesterday (Thursday), Watford confirmed they will make their decision on whether to report their Championship rivals to the authorities today.

Mackay, who was first-team coach under Rodgers, said: “I do not know how he [Rodgers] can know that [Smith’s intentions] because the club haven’t given Reading permission to speak with the player and Tommy has absolutely not come to me and asked to leave the club, so I do not understand it.”

Russo enjoyed a good relationship with Rodgers until the Northern Irishman’s decision to return to Reading, where he was a player and a coach for more than ten years.

But in a statement released by Watford on Wednesday night, Russo said: “I am somewhat disturbed as to how Brendan knows Tommy’s future intentions.

“His comments are not very respectful to the fans and the staff at Watford Football Club and he must not forget that Watford gave him his first managerial opportunity.”

He added: “Unless we receive the appropriate valuation for Tommy, through the correct channels, then we intend to keep the player at the club, this I can guarantee 100 per cent.”

A £1.8m bid was accepted from Sheffield United last week but the Watford Observer understands Smith is not keen on moving his family from their home in Berkhamsted.

Mackay rates Smith as one of the top three players in the Championship after being his team-mate, coach and manager.

The former Celtic defender used Kevin Doyle’s £6.5m transfer from Reading to Wolves to show that, in his opinion, Smith’s £1.8m price tag is more than justified considering Doyle scored just one more goal than the Watford man last season.

Asked if Rodgers’ comments on Smith disappointed him, Mackay said: “It is not something which I take much notice of and managers and other clubs can discuss what they want, to be honest.

“Myself, I have no comment to make on other players until I have them signed and they are sitting in front of you in a press conference.

“It is different if you are talking about someone like Cristiano Ronaldo or someone clearly not in your market place but if the player is in your market then it is disrespectful.”

He confirmed Smith was likely to feature tomorrow (Saturday) against Boreham Wood and reiterated Russo’s view that if the £1.8m valuation is not met, then the forward will stay.

Mackay stated Smith has returned to pre-season in excellent shape and said constant speculation will not affect the 29-year-old “at all”.

Mackay said: “He is an experienced professional and his professionalism is never going to be affected by stuff like this.

“I have known him very well for years and his level of training has not altered one iota.”


Your Say YourWatford

worthing_hornet, worthing says...
9:41am Fri 10 Jul 09

Sounds like the board have the bit between their teeth and are prepared to fight for what they believe in, which is a good thing as far as I am concerned. It must be frustrating for BR, having moved to a club where he thought he'd have milllions to spend only to find that the carrot dangled before his eyes is being pulled away as quickly as it was shown. Hmm that sounds familiar, and look what happened to THAT board! You'll need all the luck of the Irish this season BR cos you are not going to be seeing any money.

eltonsarmy, vegas says...
9:43am Fri 10 Jul 09

Its a must that this is stopped now so do it Jimmy, the bloke is having a laugh at our cost, he knows to much detail about our finances and its a clear fact he has been talking to Tommy. we gave him a chance and while im happy he is gone as i never trusted a word he said in the first place he is damaging our great club. I also ask all watford fans to ensure they are at reading supporting the lads in september and giving that idiot the warm reception he deserves.

jasonwatford, Watford says...
9:52am Fri 10 Jul 09

if tommy is happy and has not asked to leave then say not for sale at any price and see how things are in january...if we are doing well tom will stay if not we can then sell him. we must report reading to show everyone else we wont accept this in our club. By the way lets all give nathan ellington another shot as he was never given a chance last time with the style and time on pitch...lets be united on this if we have him on our books

rochdale away, norwich says...
9:59am Fri 10 Jul 09

this is a total no brainer for the club........report them, the Fa will do FA, but it may stop reading pi**ing about with our club. Agree with eltonsarmy, turn up en masse to give judas a warm reception........if he's still got the job

pstannard1, Watford says...
10:05am Fri 10 Jul 09

If i wasa chairman of a football club, any comment which sounds like an apparent illegal approch would be reported.

I think this matter though should be reported.

pstannard1, Watford says...
10:06am Fri 10 Jul 09

jasonwatford wrote:
if tommy is happy and has not asked to leave then say not for sale at any price and see how things are in january...if we are doing well tom will stay if not we can then sell him. we must report reading to show everyone else we wont accept this in our club. By the way lets all give nathan ellington another shot as he was never given a chance last time with the style and time on pitch...lets be united on this if we have him on our books
on the ellington front. I agree give him more time on the pitch then bobs your uncle, hes away.

welwyn 4md, WGC says...
10:10am Fri 10 Jul 09

best way to hurt reading and show our disgust is a complete no show of watford fans and save the warm reception for the home game

Berks Horn, London says...
10:16am Fri 10 Jul 09

Report them!

they-nose

Berks Horn, London says...
10:30am Fri 10 Jul 09

Unfortunately, if true, this suggests we are still hoping Reading match our valuation. Otherwise, if we were really that annoyed with them over this Russo would have told them by now that there was no way in hell that we were going to sell Smithy to them.

mellow yellow, london says...
10:31am Fri 10 Jul 09

The best way to hurt Reading is for us to sell our entire allocation and sing about Judas for the entire match. Chuck in the 'ghost' goal and a few decent shouts for the boys in yellow, but above all SING NON-STOP.

Andrew1963, Watford says...
10:51am Fri 10 Jul 09

I suggest that the board find a way to extend Smiths contract to 2012. If they do not want him to walk away next summer on a free. If Reading come up with an acceptable bid, no doubt we will snatch their hands off!

WE8BR, london says...
10:53am Fri 10 Jul 09

if he has tapped him up, then he has broken the rules, so report him... end of.

I still dont understand why we dont just keep him? surely we could borrow the 1.5 mill we will get for him, and we will be in a better position come the end of the season with him in the team? get him to sign a contract extension to ensure we dont lose him for nothing come next year?

I am sure he wants to stay anyway - its just the club cashing in on him now. But if we dont have to sell him, like JR is implying - then keep him! Sell macenuff and Jon Jo instead, which could raise about a mill? they are more replacable?

eltonsarmy, vegas says...
10:54am Fri 10 Jul 09

its not about wanting to sell tommy we have to, jimmy has said where we with cash and he has to go, his wages are 12k a week! the point is about reading and there conduct not if we should or not sell him.

JamesA, KL says...
10:56am Fri 10 Jul 09

"The best way to hurt Reading is for us to sell our entire allocation"

Yeah, let's do that. swell their coffers and boost BR's spending power. That'll really show 'em!

Best thing we can do is boycott the game altogether. Give them nothing.

worthing_hornet, worthing says...
11:03am Fri 10 Jul 09

We need to sell out our allocation and turn the away game into a home game, and roar the boys onto victory - no badness though guys we don't want fights and trouble, all the FA would then do is fine the club and even dock us points. Peacful but noisy opposition only guys, Watford FC are not thugs, lets remember that. Anyone who knows of anyone who would be planning anything other than that must stop them for the genuine fans and for the club to not be tarnished. Reading will be expecting that and their fans will want the moral high ground of any incidents.

T.O, Watford says...
11:09am Fri 10 Jul 09

JamesA wrote:
"The best way to hurt Reading is for us to sell our entire allocation"

Yeah, let's do that. swell their coffers and boost BR's spending power. That'll really show 'em!

Best thing we can do is boycott the game altogether. Give them nothing.
Boycott the game?! So our lads have no support, bad idea..
2,000 hornets will hardly swell their coffers, what will 50-60k buy?

It's about supporting the team first and foremost.
Did you not go to scum away because you gave them money?

Hexham Hornet, HEXHAM says...
11:40am Fri 10 Jul 09

Report them, certainly, and if the FA do their usual opting out of taking action then continue to harp on and tell the FA that we then would have the green light to tap up players whenever we wish.

The rules apply to everybody and should be enforced in the same way for everybody. If BR has not been speaking to TS then he is a liar, and has lied to his own press, if he has tapped up TS then he is not honest in the way he conducts himself (doesn't that mean he is a liar??). Either way BR does not come out of this looking good. I am pleased to see how professional Malky is being about this, as he is letting the Chairman do all the talking and just getting on with his job.

JamesA, KL says...
11:41am Fri 10 Jul 09

Oh I reckon they'd notice being £60k light on a gate.

Besides, having us lot shouting abuse at BR will just swell the little man's his ego (no doubt Jose will have given him some tips on handling it).

Save it for when Reading visit the Vic - if he's still in a job by then...

Prof Plum, Rickmansworth says...
11:59am Fri 10 Jul 09

Given the football authorities’ historical reluctance to use the full range of punishments available to them in cases of proven tapping up, what would be the point in reporting Judas and Reading?
Besides, the issue of who is responsible for tapping up is complicated and difficult to prove - no doubt in Smith’s case agents and the player have also played their part.
The league has the power to dock points and/or suspend a club from buying players during the transfer window if it chooses to but usually just issues a meaningless fine or a warning.

Forget it and move on. Just make sure you get a decent price for Smith.


herts hornet, watford says...
12:12pm Fri 10 Jul 09

Prof Plum wrote:
Given the football authorities’ historical reluctance to use the full range of punishments available to them in cases of proven tapping up, what would be the point in reporting Judas and Reading? Besides, the issue of who is responsible for tapping up is complicated and difficult to prove - no doubt in Smith’s case agents and the player have also played their part. The league has the power to dock points and/or suspend a club from buying players during the transfer window if it chooses to but usually just issues a meaningless fine or a warning. Forget it and move on. Just make sure you get a decent price for Smith.
Difficult to prove Prof !
what part of "i know tommy wants to join us " is not tapping up ,even if he did not and story was untrue saying he knows tells Tommy he wants him OPEN AND SHUT CASE ,throw the book at them Watford !

Prof Plum, Rickmansworth says...
12:26pm Fri 10 Jul 09

herts hornet wrote:
Prof Plum wrote:
Given the football authorities’ historical reluctance to use the full range of punishments available to them in cases of proven tapping up, what would be the point in reporting Judas and Reading? Besides, the issue of who is responsible for tapping up is complicated and difficult to prove - no doubt in Smith’s case agents and the player have also played their part. The league has the power to dock points and/or suspend a club from buying players during the transfer window if it chooses to but usually just issues a meaningless fine or a warning. Forget it and move on. Just make sure you get a decent price for Smith.
Difficult to prove Prof !
what part of "i know tommy wants to join us " is not tapping up ,even if he did not and story was untrue saying he knows tells Tommy he wants him OPEN AND SHUT CASE ,throw the book at them Watford !
You'd have to prove that Judas approached Smith and that contact wasn't the other way round - or through Smith's agent or some other third party. The whole thing is a minefield and the book that you want thrown at them is - even if it hits - unlikely to result in more than a slap on the wrists.

Hornets number 12 fan, watford says...
1:06pm Fri 10 Jul 09

I hope that Judas Rodgers does get reported and fined! I agree with the Boycott of the away game too.

GrahamTaylor, Watford says...
1:32pm Fri 10 Jul 09

LoL a game of call me bluff. Which club is stronger?

The cash strpped club or the one going for promotion?

Chris the Vic, The Vic says...
3:35pm Fri 10 Jul 09

When judas left it all happened very qickly but three things seemed to occur.

Judas had a sudden change of mind...which could indicate his mate Hammond got to him....Russo said that the royals had behaved professionally and The Royals paid us well over the release price of £500k...It suggests to me that tapping had occurred and our silence cost them money (shades of that Berbatov deal).

If Tommy has been tapped as seems likely from Judas's statement I wonder whether a few hundred thousand is being added to the £1.8m price to buy our silence again if so expect to be told that Tommy asked for a move. I really hope that if Tommy leaves, he leaves in the right way but I really dont expect us to report Reading and I reckon Tommy will end up there...just hope the compensation is good

UZZY, LONDON COLNEY says...
5:58pm Fri 10 Jul 09

Report them... Judas,Lampard Snr & Co have pi##ed all over us & will continue to do so until the Football League take action...sorry to say it,but it takes 2 to tango & Tommy isnt innocent,he must be involved some where down the line. (or his agent).

Hornet sting, Garston says...
10:57pm Fri 10 Jul 09

isnt there a possible 4000 away at reading ? Might be money but as all footy fans know to be outsung at home hurts bad !and im sure judas will not be looking forward to it and it would be nice to let him know how we feel.

Comments are closed on this article.

Malky Mackay and Jimmy Russo have both questioned how Reading would know of Tommy Smith's plans Malky Mackay and Jimmy Russo have both questioned how Reading would know of Tommy Smith's plans

Local Advertisers

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »